Automation #6 - Prevent Re-opening of Closed Tickets

Automation #6 - Prevent Re-opening of Closed Tickets



This is a monthly series where we pick some common use cases that have been either discussed or most asked about in our community and explain how they can be achieved using one of the automation capabilities in Zoho Desk.

Typically when a customer submits a support ticket, it is assigned with a status to map its journey. Zoho Desk provides you with four default statuses: Open, On hold, Escalated, Closed; along with the option to create your own statutes which can then be mapped to these default ones.  
 
Once the solution has been provided to the customer and the ticket is resolved the ticket is marked as "Closed". But the status changes from "Closed" to "Open" if the customer replies to the same ticket. While this behaviour might be useful for some businesses who prefer to continue the same thread instead of reopening a new one, some might not want to do so. To ensure the ticket stays in the closed status and start a new thread for a customer reply, you can create a Workflow Rule and map it to a custom function script to achieve the desired results.

Prerequisite:
To ensure the Closed status is maintained even if a customer replies to a ticket, perform the following steps: 
1. Go to Setup, and under Customization, click Ticket Status, uncheck the "Fall-Back To Default" checkbox against "Closed" status.
2. OrgID, to get the OrgID, navigate to "Setup >> Developer Space >> API". Note down the OrgID
To create the workflow rule, perform the following steps:

1. Go to Setup, and under Automation, click Workflows.
2. On the left panel, under Workflows, click Rules > Create Rule.
In the Basic Information section, perform the following steps:
3. In the Module drop-down menu, select Tickets.
4. Enter a name and description for the rule.
5. If you want to activate the rule right away, select the Active checkbox. Else, you can just create the rule now and activate it later on the Rules page.
6. Click Next.
In the Execute on section, perform the following steps:
7. Select the Customer Reply checkbox to execute this rule every time a customer responds to a ticket.  
8. Click Next.
9. In the Criteria section, set the criteria as "Status is Closed" and click "Next"
In the Actions section, perform the following steps:
10. Click the + icon under "Action" and select "New" next to Custom Functions
11. Enter a name and description for the custom function.
12. In the script window, input the Custom Function you find below:
  1. numberOfHours = 48;
  2. orgId = "Paste Org Id here";
  3. //Please paste your OrgID
  4. TicketInfo = zoho.desk.getRecordById(orgId,"tickets",TicketID);
  5. lastModified = TicketInfo.get("closedTime").toTime("yyyy-MM-dd'T'HH:mm:ss");
  6. status = TicketInfo.get("status");
  7. hoursBetween = now.hoursBetween(lastModified).abs();
  8. if(hoursBetween >= numberOfHours)
  9. {
  10. threadResponse = zoho.desk.getRelatedRecords(orgId, "threads", "tickets", TicketID);
  11. if(threadResponse.get("data") != null)
  12. {
  13. latestThreadID = threadResponse.get("data").get(0).get("id");
  14. splitTicketResponse = zoho.desk.ticket.split(orgId, TicketID, latestThreadID);
  15. info "splitTicketResponse ::::" + splitTicketResponse;
  16. info "======================================================";
  17. NewTicketNumber = splitTicketResponse.get("ticketNumber");
  18. NewTicketID = splitTicketResponse.get("id");
  19. }
  20. }
  21. else
  22. {
  23. jsonString = {"status":"Open"};
  24. TicketResponse = zoho.desk.update(orgId, "tickets", TicketID, jsonString);
  25. info TicketResponse;
  26. }

NOTE:
Line 1 numberOfHours = 48, refers to the hours post which the new response received in a existing ticket should be split as new ticket. You can replace the number of hours based on your requirement.
Line 2 replace the orgId.

13. Click Edit Arguments
14. In the Name field type TicketID, and from the Value drop-down list select Ticket Id under Ticket Information. 
15. Click "Save" to save the custom function
16. Click "Save" again to save the workflow.

These steps would ensure that when a ticket is marked Closed, it stays in the Closed status, even if a customer replies after the mentioned hours. But also ensure that the new reply is added as a new ticket so you don't miss anything!

    • Sticky Posts

    • Register for Zoho Desk Beta Community

      With the start of the year, we have decided to take a small step in making the life of our customers a little easier. We now have easy access to all our upcoming features and a faster way to request for beta access. We open betas for some of our features

    • Share your Zoho Desk story with us!

      Tell us how you use Zoho Desk for your business and inspire others with your story. Be it a simple workflow rule that helps you navigate complex processes or a macro that saves your team a lot of time; share it here and help the community learn and grow with shared knowledge. 

    • Tip #1: Learn to pick the right channels

      Mail, live chat, telephony, social media, web forms—there are so many support channels out there. Trying to pick the right channels to offer your customers can get pretty confusing. Emails are most useful when the customer wants to put things on record. However, escalated or complicated issues should not be resolved over email because it's slow and impersonal.  When you need immediate responses, live chat is more suitable. It's also quick and convenient, so it's the go-to channel for small issues. 

    • Welcome to Zoho Desk Community - Say hello here!

      Hello everyone! Though we have been here for a while, it’s time to formally establish the Zoho Desk Community; we’re really happy to have you all here! This can be the place where you take a moment to introduce yourself to the rest of the community. We’d love to hear all about you, what you do, what company or industry you work for, how you use Zoho Desk and anything else that you will like to share! Here’s a little about me. I am Chinmayee. I have been associated with Zoho since 2014. I joined here

    • Webinar 1: Blueprint for Customer Service

      With the launch of a host of new features in Zoho Desk, we thought it’ll be great to have a few webinars to help our customers make the most of them. We’re starting off with our most talked about feature, Blueprint in Zoho Desk. You can register for the Blueprint webinar here: The webinar will be delivered by our in-house product experts. This is a good opportunity to ask questions to our experts and understand how Blueprint can help you automate your service processes. We look forward to seeing

    • Recent Topics

    • File Upload and Add via API

      I've been attempting to upload to via the Files api and I have been hitting the wall with actually getting the file to attach. What type is the API expecting ? Base64 Encoded ? When I do I get a 414 Error. I would appreciate your help as I am currently

    • Is this a valid email from Zoho or a scam?

      Hi, I received an email advising me to update MX records for Zoho mail. Is it legitimate? Thanks, Nelson. Dear Admin, You may know that your domain (eg, yourcompany.com) has an MX record that points to an email server configured to process email for your domain. We have noticed that some of our customers have used Zoho IP address (instead of DNS server name) in their MX records to specify the mail server. This is NOT recommended practice. Vendors will sometimes change IP addresses for number of valid

    • Unable to add estimate field to estimate template

      I have the field "SKU" as part of my service data. I can also see it as a column when displaying the list of services. However, I have no way to include it on my estimate template because the field is not showing as a column field to include for the service/part

    • Add Pinned Tickets to top of queue

      As an IT Helpdesk, we have some tickets where they will need to be looked at daily over a week or 2, and the ability to pin a ticket to the front/top of the queue would be handy as we can be reminded to take a look, rather than placing them on hold and

    • Holding Shift to keep selected tickets

      It is annoying trying to change the category of tickets and then closing them. You have to select them one by one, no way to 'hold down left click and drag your mouse down to select multiple'. Once you have selected them and you change the category, you

    • CRM HAS BEEN SOOO SLOW For Days 05/15/25

      I have fantastic Wifi speed and have zero issues with other websites, apps, or programs. It takes an excruciatingly amount of time to simply load a record, open an email, compose an email, draft a new template, etc. Am I in a subset/region of subscribers

    • Including attachments with estimates

      How can attachments be included when an estimate is sent/emailed and when downloaded as a .pdf? Generally speaking, attachments should be included as part of an estimate package. Ultimately, this is also true for work orders and invoices.

    • What’s New in Zoho Inventory | April 2025

      Hello users, April has been a big month in Zoho Inventory! We’ve rolled out powerful new features to help you streamline production, optimise stock management, and tailor your workflows. While several updates bring helpful enhancements, three major additions

    • Formula Module how to convert to percentage

      Hello There, I have create a formula field and i want the outcome to be in percentage how do i do that This is my formula ${Deals.Forecast Revenue Per Year}/${Deals.Annual Processing Volume} I have try ${Deals.Forecast Revenue Per Year}/${Deals.Annual

    • Same users on different accounts

      I have an issue I need help with. Whilst trialing ZOHO CRM I created the following: Account1 using myname@myorganisation.com.au and 2 personal emails Account2 using a personal email and 2 users sales1@myorganisation.com.au and sales2@myorganisation.com.au

    • Error "The SMTP server requires a secure connection or the client was not authenticated. The server response was: 5.5.1 Authentication Required"

      Hi, I'm trying to send an email via the SMTP server using C# code but getting the following error: "The SMTP server requires a secure connection or the client was not authenticated. The server response was: 5.5.1 Authentication Required" I know the username and password are correct and I can login via the web interface an send email via this account no problems. Here is my code - can any body shed any light on why this would happen? Putting an invalid password gives the same error. I also have disabled

    • Existing subform data is being changed when new subform entries are added

      I'm having trouble with existing subform data being changed when new subform entries are created. I have the following setup to track registrations for a girl scout troop: Main Form: Child Subform: Registrations The data are a one-to-many relationship where each Child record has many Registrations (new Registration will be created for each year the child is in the troop.) Per the instructions, I have created the subfom, added it to the main form, gone back to the subform and created the bi-directional

    • How to get custom estimate field to display on existing or new services?

      I am using FSM. I recently added a new custom field to Service Details to help categorize my services. I can see the newly added field as a column on the service list view. However, when attempting to update an existing or create a new service, I don't

    • How to add a contact ID to contacts I'm importing with migration

      New user, business owner here, not a data specialist. I'm attempting to migrate import data from my old CRM, Daylite, via a .csv file. I feel like I've mapped the columns in the .csv file, however when I click save and next, I get a message saying the

    • FSM Job Sheets data to CRM

      Hello, is there anyway of getting the data collected in the job sheets into the CRM. We are collecting inspection data which we were using zoho forms for but the job sheets in fsm seem like a lot better way to collect it but we need to be able to get

    • Automate Ticket Assignment to Contact or Account Owner Using Custom Action

      Teltroz Inc specializes in data science, data analytics, and big data technologies. Serving a wide range of customers from large to medium-sized businesses, security has been their top priority. The firm uses Zoho Desk to enhance their business operations,

    • Whats the Time out Limit for API Calls from Deluge?

      Hi Creator Devs, We are making API calls to third party server via Deluge. Getting this error message: Error at line : 24, The task has been terminated since the API call is taking too long to respond. Please try again after sometime. Whats the default

    • Footer in PDF template doesn't stay at the bottom of the page

      When setting up a PDF template there is an option for a header / footer. The header stays at the top of the page however the footer does not. It appears the footer actually serves no purpose as it seems to rise up to underneath the header (see image). Is there a way to lock the footer to the bottom of the page? Otherwise what is the point of it? Image demonstrating what I mean. https://ibb.co/cJY1xZ4

    • Hiring Staff Accountant in San Diego with ZohoBooks Experience

      Hello, We are a San Diego, CA company looking for an experienced Staff accountant or controller that has ZohoBooks experience for a full-time position. Please reach out if interested. Best, Ben

    • Unveiling Cadences: Redefining CRM interactions with automated sequential follow-ups

      Last modified on 01/04/2024: Cadences is now available for all Zoho CRM users in all data centres (DCs). Note that it was previously an early access feature, available only upon request, and was also known as Cadences Studio. As of April 1, 2024, it's

    • Third party apps for my mail

      Hello im new here and i have a very important issue. A third party company uses one of my emails to send invoices to our customers. My problem is that cannot connect to zoho mail server. my imap settings are corrent imappro.zoho.eu 993 smtppto.zoho.eu

    • Deal Product reference

      Hello All, I'm trying to use Zoho Writer to dynamically create a statement of work document. Our statement of work is heavily dependent on what products are included in the deal. As such, I need to be able to add or remove sections of text depending on

    • Kit Items Breaking Automations - "Provide mapped components for all kit items"

      This has been brought up in other threads, but I believe this issue warrants its own topic. Whenever a sales document (Estimate, Sales Order, Invoice) is created or manipulated programmatically, trying to include a Kit as an Item throws this error: "Provide

    • Outage?

      Is there an outage? Everytime I try to access Zoho FSM (web, as admin) I get a blank screen.

    • Flutter Plugin Compatibility Issue: Unresolved Reference to FlutterPluginRegistry in zohodesk_portal_apikit

      I am integrating the zohodesk_portal_apikit Flutter plugin (version 2.2.1) into my Flutter project, but I am encountering a build error related to an unresolved reference to FlutterPluginRegistry in the file ZDPBaseActivityAwarePlugin.kt. Below is the

    • How to set the value of the Phone field importing contacts in Zoho Desk

      Hi everyone, i'm new in Zoho Desk, we're setting up the environment and i'm importing contacts from another CRM using a file CSV and i'm getting a problem with phone numbers (italian): the leading zero is cut away, also if the value is inside double quotes.

    • Have you checked your Email headers for DKIM Failure?

      Have you taken a look at your email headers for DKIM failures even with DKIM set up properly? I've had DKIM successfully set up for many months. My account currently shows Email Verified and Authenticated. Big green check marks. Email Relay is also showing

    • If Formula with Abs and Now included!

      Hi all, Having a bit of trouble with an If formula when creating a formula field with currency return type. This is what I've got: If(Now()>=${Agreement History.Rent Review Due}, '${Agreement History.Holdover Price}', 'Abs(${Agreement History.Rent Achieved

    • How to normalize CRM module when integrating with Survey?

      This question is about the problem with many-to-many relationships and Survey. One of the things our organization does is track people in our program and their jobs. We get new information from the people three times annually through Zoho Surveys. Survey

    • IMPORTRANGE Spreadsheets

      I am trying to importrange a spreadsheet into another, but an error keep appearing saying NOT LINKED. Noting that I've linked it. I've tried to publish both sheets and re-apply the formula many times but nothing is working. I don't know what can I do

    • Zoho Desk to Jira > Automatic Creation ?

      I've set up the integration for Jira and Zoho Desk, but when I create a test ticket as a customer nothing is sent to Jira automatically - is this correct ? I can manually link to Jira using the "More Actions", but I was expecting the issue to be created

    • How to create Comparison across Period chart in a dashboard?

      Hi all How can I create this chart in a custom dashboard? The issue for me is that this chart is very small. The CRM module (unlike Projects module) has no ability to expand a chart. I want to make it larger, but also want to include it in a custom Forecast

    • Trouble fetching custom fields from Zoho Booking

      I'm following the instructions from here : https://help.zoho.com/portal/en/kb/flow/user-guide/app-specific-documentation/articles/zoho-bookings#1_Problem_with_accessing_custom_fields But I can't get this to work. Here is the result of a test booking :

    • How to change an employee mail id

      Hi, Does the administrator have the rights to edit an  employees mail id. 

    • Is it possible to set create deal checked by default when converting a lead?

      In our company whenever a lead is converted we make a deal. It is a pain to have to check the box every time. I would prefer if it was just a default behavior and the box wasn't even there. But it would be fine if the box could be checked by default.

    • Sync Creator form submissions to WorkDrive folder

      I've made 10 Creator applications, and need to sync my each application's submissions into a WorkDrive folder. I need the form submissions to be PDF file type and sync to a specific folder for documentation purposes. I have tried to use a workflow, but

    • How do you map a user picklist field to another user picklist field.

      In Zoho Projects, I'm trying to map a custom field (user picklist) in Task Details to a field (user picklist) in the Project Details. How do you get the two to map to each other? This is what I currently have that works for my other fields but doesn't

    • Introducing Seamless Communication with WhatsApp Integration in Zoho Recruit

      Hello everyone, We are thrilled to announce that we have just launched an incredible new feature in Zoho Recruit that will revolutionize your recruitment process. With the integration of WhatsApp into Zoho Recruit, you can now seamlessly connect with

    • Custom Function : Copy multilookup field to text field

      Hi, I'm a newbie on function programming, I try to copy text from a multi lookup field named "societe" to a text field named "societe2". I've used this code. In deluge script it seems to work, but when I trigger this function it doesn't work (Societe2

    • Send a new invoice data from Books to local certified solution via API json due local compliance

      Greetings, I hope you are doing well and staying safe. Due to local compliance regulations, I am required to issue invoices exclusively using locally certified software, which Zoho Books is not. However, we would like to continue using Zoho Books, so

    • Next Page