Collections Management: #3 Tackling Payment Failures

Sam refreshed the dashboard.

"Payment failed".

Same customer. Same subscription. This is happening for the third time. He sends a usual email: "Your renewal payment failed again. Could you please check and retry?"

A couple of days passed, and there was still no response. Sam calls the customer, "Hey, could you update your card details or retry the payment?"

"Oh, yes, yes.. I'll do it today. Just remind me later this evening", the customer responded casually. That "remind me later" became multiple reminders. By the time the payment finally went through, Sam had invested more time following up on one failed transaction than on handling five smooth customers.

At that moment, he realised something important. Failed payments are a niche issue, but following up on them is the real problem.

Dunning to Rescue 

Dunning management in Zoho Billing takes over the moment a payment fails and handles payment recovery automatically. All you need to do is configure the rule for it.

Standard Dunning 

The standard dunning process enables you to configure retries for both online and offline subscriptions.

For online payments, such as card, ACH, and UPI mandates, Zoho Billing automatically retries the payment at predefined intervals, for example, on Days 1, 3, and 7. Whether the payment attempt is successful or not, the customer is eventually notified. The subscription remains active during these retries until it reaches the last and final attempt. Businesses can configure whether the subscription should remain active or be cancelled after all retries are complete.

For offline payments, such as cash or bank transfers, dunning doesn't retry. Instead, Zoho Billing automatically sends follow-up reminders at increasing urgency. Every delayed payment receives a structured and consistent notification sequence. Even for offline dunning, businesses can configure the final action to be taken on the subscription after it has been escalated to the customer.

Advanced Dunning 

Pause & Resume Dunning 

Sometimes, customers genuinely need time to update their payment details, talk to their bank, or resolve a card issue. Now, dunning can be paused for a specific invoice with the following conditions:

• The resume date must be earlier than the next billing date.

• The customer can manually resume the dunning process at any time before the scheduled resume date.

When dunning resumes:

• If the selected resume date falls between scheduled retries, the next retry will occur on the next scheduled retry date.

• If the resume date is after the final retry, Zoho Billing automatically triggers a retry within a day.

This helps businesses stay structured while giving customers time to breathe.

Stop Dunning 

At any point, you can decide to stop pursuing payment retry for an invoice under dunning. Zoho Billing allows you to,

• Stop the dunning process entirely, removing the subscription from the dunning flow.

• Mark the next retry as the final attempt for the auto-charge subscription. 

If the upcoming retry is set as the final attempt (whether successful or not), the configured action under the standard dunning rule for the final action will be triggered.

On-Demand Dunning  

Zoho Billing provides an option to send a link to update payment information when we notify customers of payment failure. This enables customers to update their information instantly without needing to navigate the interface. If a customer updates their card or fixes a billing issue and says, "Can you try charging again now?"

You don't have to wait for the next scheduled dunning to attempt the payment. Zoho Billing offers an On-demand Retry option, enabling businesses to try charging the customer immediately and directly from the invoice. This avoids waiting time and reduces the risk of failure.

Multi-Dunning Rules 

Not all customers should be treated as the same. Some require more time for grace, while others need quick closure. Zoho Billing supports multiple dunning rules, allowing businesses to assign different retry strategies to different subscriptions.

Each rule includes:

• A personalised retry schedule (number of retries + interval)

• Unique email template for communication.

• Criteria that determine when the rule applies.

• Priority order (Zoho matches rules based on priority)

You can set these criteria based on,

• Customers

• Subscriptions

• Plans or Product

• Invoice value

• Currency

• Billing Frequency.

A total of six unique rules can be created, including the default one. High-value customers can receive more retries and personalised emails, while other customers can have shorter cycles.

​
Reports Based on Dunning 

When payment fails or an invoice enters a dunning cycle, it's more about the retries than the visibility that a business should get. The Under-Risk report in Zoho Billing provides businesses with a real-time view of all transactions currently under the dunning process. It highlights which customers are at risk of churn or suspension, how long payments have been pending and which retry stage each invoice is in.

​
To track down customers who dropped off due to churn, Zoho Billing offers the Churned after Retries report. This report helps businesses re-engage with those customers, as the downgrade/churn was not intended to occur. This gives a high chance of winning them back.

​
What Dunning Management Does to Business 

With these capabilities, Zoho Billing shifts the handling of failed payments from a reactive to a proactive approach. Payment retries are automated, and customers receive notifications without requiring manual intervention. Businesses can pause, stop or define a final retry action. Sending personalised emails and providing time for customers based on their worth ensures reliability and trust.

On the whole, the automated dunning process helps businesses to keep the payment process organised and, at the same time, reduce the risk of losing control over failing payments.

 

Up Next: Collection as a Journey

 

 

• Topic Participants

• Hari Hara Sudhan. S

  

• Sticky Posts

• Community Learning Series | Digest #5 — September 2020

  Dear customers, We're happy to bring you the September edition of our #CommunityDigest! Keep track of your subscription KPIs right from your smartphone: Last month, we enhanced our Android mobile app to help our customers get daily updates on their business health. We got to know from a lot of customers that this has made their job much more easier because they no longer have to keep a reminder to manually check on the previous day's revenue or activations. If you have not downloaded it yet, here's

• Community Learning Series | Digest #4 - August 2020

  Dear customers, We hope you're staying safe and healthy. I'm happy to bring you the fourth edition of our #CommunityDigest with some brand-new updates from us. 1. Daily Business Updates (for Android users) The Zoho Subscriptions Android app has got a cool new update: You can now get a push notification to your smartphone that lets you know how many activations and cancellations have taken place, and what's the net revenue for the previous day. The best part is, you can tell the app when exactly you

• Community Learning Series | Digest #3 - July 2020

  Dear customers, We hope you're staying safe and healthy. We're glad to bring you the July edition of our #CommunityDigest. New community members can view our previous newsletters here. This time, we have two major updates and three interesting topics for you: 1. Zoho Subscriptions Developer Community Since the inception of Zoho Subscriptions, our team believed that the recurring billing platform we provide should be able to offer an extensive API library that empowers businesses to automate most

• Introducing: Community Learning Series | Digest #1 - May 2020

  Dear customers, We hope you are staying safe and healthy. Helping businesses manage their customer subscriptions more efficiently has always been, and always will be, our goal at Zoho Subscriptions. We strongly believe this is possible if we grow together as a community and share what we know with each other. To nurture this shared learning experience, here is our brand-new Community Learning Series! ​ Welcome to the first edition of our digest! Each edition of our community digest includes guides

• Recent Topics

• Get Sales Orders Related to Inventory Item

  Dear Team, I'm just wondering if there is a way to get a list of all Sales Orders related to a specific Inventory Item. I did search all articles but couldn't find any article that could help.

• Endpoint Central Cloud Asset Update from Fresh Service

  All, Does anyone use the asset management feature in Fresh Service? I'd like some help on building a flow to update asset attributes in Endpoint Central Cloud based off of an update to that same asset in Fresh Service. The trigger is "asset is updated"

• Zoho Flow Export to Deluge

  It would be great to take a user built zoho flow and export the entire flow as a deluge script including having multiple connected applications (showing the API connections and webhooks) and different functionality in the other applications interacting

• Action Iteration/Loop using Zoho Flow

  Trying to use Zoho Flow for automating following Context - A zoho form entry which has image upload field with upto 5 images setting and files are saved into Workdrive. After form is submitted need to create folder based on some fields and move files

• Zoho Flow - Unable to evaluate formatDate with Zoho Invoice Date Field for Calendar Integration

  Hello Community, I'm trying to automate the creation of all-day events in Zoho Calendar whenever a new invoice is created in Zoho Invoice. I'm using Zoho Flow for this automation. My Goal: When an invoice is created with a specific "Event Date," I want

• Zoho Inventory Sales Order Items

  I'm trying to build automation using Zoho Flow to add items to a Sales Order. In the automation options for both "create sales order" and "update sales order", The item ID is required. However, when I update the Sales Order, it's just replacing the item

• Permissions for Azure Devops connection

  I am trying to set up a connection with our Azure DevOps org but it keeps giving me this error. On Azure I should be able to have admin-level access to everything. Can you please point me to which permission this is checking for so I can enable it?

• Best way to start zoho inventory with bulk openning stock

  We are already using zoho book since long time for cars trading company. Now to streamline more, would like to import the excel data of closing stock of inventory to zoho inventory and to start on. Since we need to track each VIN (unique vehicle id number)

• My IMAP mail suddenly stopped working

  On my iPhone and iPad, IMAP stopped working for my Zoho account with the error "User name or password incorrect" and "Invalid credentials failure" however I was able to access via web with the same credentials. Also stopped working on Apple Mail client.

• Confused by the distiction between matched and categorized when reconciling a bank statement an how to

  I used to use quickbooks. In quickbooks, it was possible to use the check writing feature to add an expense that was on the bank statement that did not go through the AP and check writing process. I would write a check, assign it a number like etf (for

• Not Receiving OTP • https://voters.eci.gov.in/home/family

  Hello Customer, Greetings from Zoho Mail. Upon a detailed review of our delivery logs, we can confirm that other Zoho Mail users are successfully receiving OTP emails from eci.gov.in. However, in your specific case, it appears that the OTP emails are

• WorkDrive for Excel Add on

  Dear Sir/Madam Have installed Workdrive for Microsoft add on But unable to view the same added in Excel

• Splitting Transactions in Zoho Books

  I have read in past forum posts that the ability to split bank transactions would likely be implemented - it's definitely a typical accounting program feature.  I'm new to Zoho and thought I'd found nirvana until I realized this feature doesn't seem to

• Zoho Calendar s’enrichit avec une intégration à Zoho People et Zoho Cliq

  Les journées de travail ne se déroulent jamais exactement comme prévu. Une conversation informelle devient une séance d’échange d'idées, une absence modifie un planning, et votre agenda se retrouve vite décalé par rapport à la réalité. Chez Zoho Calendar,

• Holidays

  Hi; For defining Holidays, you need to add logic to handle the year as well as the month & day. We need to be able to enter Holidays for the next year. I need to add a holiday for January 2, 2017, but I can't until January 1st, which is a Sunday and we

• Zoho public comments are confusing and unnecessary

  Hi, we use zoho desk and have issues with public comments. We started using them because the "Reply" option just seemed very clumsy because of the following reasons: - the top "Reply" button starts what seems to be a regular email, showing the entire

• Zoho API - ticket creation - Validation failed for the condition : Ticket Status Info should not be empty

  Hi ! I'm trying to create ticket through Zoho API, and I'm getting a 422 response : "Validation failed for the condition : Ticket Status Info should not be empty" My request looks like this : curl --location 'https://desk.zoho.eu/api/v1/tickets' \ --header

• Deleting unwanted ticket replies

  Hello, In a Zoho Desk Ticket thread, sometimes one of the recipients has auto-reply activated. This creates a new message in the Ticket thread that not only pollutes the thread, but most importantly cannot be replied properly because usually auto-reply e-mails don't do "reply all", so the other recipients are not included. I want to delete such a message in the Ticket thread. I searched the help of Zoho Desk, but only found a way to mark as Spam (https://help.zoho.com/portal/kb/articles/marking-support-tickets-as-spam)

• System-generated support email added in CC on “Reply All”

  Hi, I recently set up Zoho Desk for a client and we are trying to prevent the Zoho Desk system-generated support email address (not the mailbox used as the department’s "From address") from being automatically added in CC when agents use “Reply All” on

• Applying Excess Payments & Conflict Invoices Due to Cancelled Items

  I’m running into several issues that appear to stem from deeper-than-expected overlap between Zoho Finance (Books/Inventory) and Zoho POS. The level of coupling between these systems seems greater than what was originally communicated, and it’s leading

• Convenience Fees

  I use Zoho Invoice for invoicing my billboard customers.  I have a few customers that want to pay using credit cards and ACH.  As a result, I have integrated an Online Payment Gateway (Stripe) for these customers.  I currently charge these customers a "Convenience Fee" of 3% for using this service as I typically only take checks as payment (and the gateway charges 2.9% + $0.30 per transaction).  I do this by creating a separate line item on the invoice and adding 3% to it.  I would like to offer

• HTML Tags added to Reports with Notes

  Recently Zoho added the ability to markup text within notes. That way, users can change font size, colors, etc. It's a great change. However, since the change, reports that include a column for "Note Content" are printing HTML tags within the report.

• New Feature: Audit Log in Zoho Bookings

  Greetings from the Zoho Bookings team! We’re excited to introduce Audit Log, a new feature designed to help you track all key actions related to your appointments. With Audit Log, you can maintain transparency, strengthen security, and ensure accountability.

• Bill automation in Zoho Books

  Hi I am looking for 3rd-party options for bill automation in zoho which are economical and preferably have accurate scanning. What options do I have? Zoho's native scanning is a bit pricey

• Restrict Payment Methods

  Allow us to restrict certain payment methods specific for each customer.

• Emails Getting Delay Error Messages - Status: 451

  Hi. Hoping someone can help. I've been using Zoho for over a year now with no problems at all. Today, the majority of my emails I send out or reply to are getting this error: This message was created automatically by mail delivery system. THIS IS A WARNING MESSAGE ONLY. YOU DO NOT NEED TO RESEND YOUR MESSAGE. The original message was received at Sun, 22 Dec 2019 18:20:19 -0800 from wazza@amninjas.com [wazza@amninjas.com] ----- The following addresses had fatal errors ----- [Status: ERROR, Address:

• Add Domain

  Hello Zoho Support, My Zoho Sites project accidentally auto-added domains with http:// prefix and duplicated domain entries. Current domains list shows: http://www.kinhtethethao.com.vn (Primary – cannot be removed) http://www.kinhtethethao.com.vn (verification

• Kaizen #221: Workflow & Actions Reports APIs

  Over the last few weeks, we have joined Zylker Cloud Services as they restructured their automation ecosystem using Workflow APIs and Actions APIs. Along the way, we discovered how to audit workflows, update old rules, create new ones, and manage associated

• Having an Issue with the Entity ID

  I'm having an issue when trying to use Zoho Flow and the notes function. I currently have it set up when a new response comes into a particular form, all of their responses will go into the notes section of their contact on the CRM. I'm currently mapping

• For Each Loop in Zoho Flow

  I am using Zoho flow to create rows in an google sheets for every new order in Shopify but the issue is that it is creating one row per order and all line items are comma separated values but I want separate rows for each line item. Is there a way to

• Debug and Test not receiving updates

  Hello, I've been trying to debug two of my simple flows between Zoho Projects and Clockify but it seems like the Debug and Test feature is not working for me. When I click the Play button on any of the flows and then perform the trigger actions nothing

• Attendance, Reimagined: Smarter Views for Teams and Individuals

  Tracking attendance shouldn’t feel like a chore. With the revamped Attendance module UI, Zoho FSM makes it easier than ever to monitor work hours, check-in activity, and team availability—whether you’re managing an entire workforce or just keeping an

• Logistics Industry: Learn to create amazing appointment scheduling sites

  In the logistics industry, the quality of service is something that cannot be shown to others unless they experience it.  Sure, there are metrics that show how you fare when compared to your competition, but then, it only communicates little with respect to quality. The usual route which firms in logistics took are advertisements, to which the internet has opened alternatives in today’s digital age like websites and appointment scheduling sites. A great online presence can help you communicate with

• Customer Management: # 1 Pick a Convenient Way to Onboard Customer

  When Meera opened her bookstore, onboarding customers was effortless. A customer walked in, picked a book and left with a handwritten bill. As the store gained popularity, things changed. " Can I place an order over the phone?" a customer asked one day.

• Tracking Emails sent through Outlook

  All of our sales team have their Outlook 365 accounts setup with IMAP integration. We're trying to track their email activity that occurs outside the CRM. I can see the email exchanges between the sales people and the clients in the contact module. But

• Fetch ALL items from Inventory and send to Google Sheet using Flow

  The title says it all -- I want to fetch the Item name, SKU, Purchase rate, and Sales rate for ALL items in Zoho Inventory and have them populate a tab in an existing Google Sheet. I have already successfully made this work for one item, so the flow is

• Why Document Integrity Matters at Every Stage of the Contract Lifecycle

  Contracts are legal records that must stay authentic and traceable from creation to expiry or termination. In Zoho Contracts, several design decisions focus on protecting the integrity of every document. These measures ensure that no important details

• affichage pièces jointes impossible

  Bonjour, aujourd'hui je n'arrive pas à afficher ni à télécharger les pièces jointes dans ZOHO CRM. J'utilise Chrome, j'ai vidé les caches et les cookies. Mais cela ne change rien. Merci de votre aide

• Reminder to renew subscription.

  Whenever I try to add to one of my notes a " renew your subscription" window pops out and won't Close disallowing me to edit. Why should I renew my subscription on an application with at best such bugs and at worse such underhanded ways to force ren

• Fields not coming through, not pulling data

  Forgive the noviceness of my vocabulary. I am in Zoho flow connecting CRM and Projects. When an opportunity hits a certain stage, it will create the project in Projects, and bring in data from the opportunity. Everything is working, except for two fields

• Next Page