URL Aliases Not Displaying Properly in Received Emails

Trying to figure out why in my email I'm not seeing the a URL alias and instead seeing the original URL used to track the number of clicks. For example in Zoho Mail I see:

https://cts.vrmailer1.com/click?sk=aEIwB2JgWjBL3ejFVAOkF5F9WS9q0-KVs96VajAV3ZGw=/aHR0cDovL3d3dy5vcnBoYW5lZC1sYW5kLmNvbS8=/YNuA5p2sV2rOOypZ_1kXEw==&merge_field_type=(?x-mi:(?%3C=href=)[%5Cs]*['%22](?%3Curl%3E[%5E%7B'%22].+?)['%22])&href_id_source=vr2-href-id-source-6

Instead of seeing:

http://www.orphaned-land.com/

In another account I have in Gmail, I see the correct URL.