Bug: OAuth 2.0 State Parameter fails with Pipe Delimiters (RFC 6749 Non-Compliance)

Bug: OAuth 2.0 State Parameter fails with Pipe Delimiters (RFC 6749 Non-Compliance)

I've discovered a bug in how Zoho's API Console handles the OAuth 2.0 authorization flow when the state parameter contains pipe characters (|), and I'm hoping the Zoho team can address this in a future update.
The Issue
Zoho's OAuth 2.0 implementation for server-based client applications uses the standard authorization endpoint:
https://accounts.zoho.com/oauth/v2/auth?response_type=code
&client_id=<client_id>
&scope=<scope>
&redirect_uri=<redirect_uri>
&access_type=offline
&state=<state_value>
While Zoho's documentation does not explicitly list the state parameter, it is a standard part of the OAuth 2.0 specification (RFC 6749 Section 4.1.1) and is widely used for CSRF protection and maintaining application state through the authorization flow.
However, when the state parameter contains pipe characters (|), Zoho's authorization server fails to process the request correctly, preventing users from authorizing the connection. This occurs whether the pipe characters are URL-encoded (%7C) or left unencoded.
The Problem
The pipe character is a standard delimiter in multi-part state values, particularly when passing a combination of a CSRF token and a return URL. This behavior—failing on both encoded and unencoded pipe characters—is often indicative of overly restrictive input validation or a "leaky" WAF/Proxy layer that decodes parameters before the application logic can handle them.
State Value As Sent in URL Result
abc123xyz state=abc123xyz ✓ Works correctly
session_12345 state=session_12345 ✓ Works correctly
user|action|timestamp state=user|action|timestamp
(unencoded pipes)
✗ Authorization fails
user|action|timestamp state=user%7Caction%7Ctimestamp
(URL-encoded pipes)
✗ Authorization fails
user:action:timestamp state=user%3Aaction%3Atimestamp ? Not tested
Note: Pipe characters cause failures whether URL-encoded or not. Other special characters/delimiters have not been tested and may or may not exhibit similar issues.
RFC 6749 Compliance Issue
Section 4.1.1 - Authorization Request:
"state: RECOMMENDED. An opaque value used by the client to maintain state between the request and callback."
Section 4.1.2 - Authorization Response:
"state: REQUIRED if the 'state' parameter was present in the client authorization request. The exact value received from the client."
The RFC explicitly defines the state parameter as an opaque value. This means:
  • The Authorization Server should not be looking "inside" or parsing the string at all
  • The state value must pass through the authorization process unchanged
  • Any URL-encoded characters should be handled transparently
  • The exact value received must be returned to the client in the redirect
Key Point: By definition, an "opaque" parameter means the authorization server must treat it as a data blob—accepting it, storing it, and returning it without any interpretation or transformation.
Current Behavior vs Expected Behavior
Current Behavior Expected Behavior (Per RFC 6749)
1. Client sends: state=user|action|123
(or state=user%7Caction%7C123)
2. Zoho fails to parse the state parameter
3. Authorization server returns HTTP 400 Bad Request
4. User cannot authorize the connection
1. Client sends: state=user|action|123

2. Zoho treats state as opaque data blob
3. User authorizes the connection
4. Redirect includes the exact value received:
state=user|action|123
(or consistently encoded as sent)
The Current Workaround (Suboptimal)
Important: The workarounds below only apply if you have control over the client application generating the OAuth request. If you're integrating with a third-party application that sets the state parameter (e.g., integration platforms, SaaS tools, enterprise software), you have no ability to modify the state value and therefore no workaround is available. You are completely blocked from completing the OAuth flow.
For developers who do control the client application, you must avoid pipe characters entirely:
// Instead of using pipes as delimiters:
state = csrf_token + "|" + user_id + "|" + redirect_path;
// ❌ This breaks Zoho's authorization flow

// Developers must use alternative approaches:
state = csrf_token + "_SEP_" + user_id + "_SEP_" + redirect_path;
// or
state = base64_encode(json_encode({"csrf": token, "user": id, "path": path}));
// or
state = csrf_token; // Store other data server-side keyed by CSRF token
Problems with these workarounds:
  • Requires refactoring existing codebases that use pipe delimiters
  • Base64 encoding increases state parameter length significantly, risking URL length limits (particularly in older browsers and some enterprise proxies which enforce ~2000 character limits)
  • Server-side storage approach adds complexity, database overhead, and potential race conditions
  • Inconsistent with how the same code works with other OAuth providers (Google, Microsoft, etc.)
  • Developers may not discover this issue until production deployment
  • Custom delimiters (like _SEP_) are non-standard and may conflict with actual data values
What Should Happen Instead
Proposed Solution:
Zoho's authorization server should properly handle URL-encoded pipe characters (%7C) in the state parameter, as required by RFC 6749. The state value must be treated as an opaque data blob.
Technical Requirement: Treat state as a Data Blob
1. Input Accept %7C (and other encoded characters) as valid parts of the query string without triggering validation errors or WAF rules
2. Persistence Store the string exactly as received during the user's login/consent session—do not decode, parse, or transform
3. Output Append the exact string back to the redirect_uri without additional transformations that might strip or corrupt the delimiters
This approach:
  • Complies with RFC 6749's requirement to return "the exact value received"
  • Follows the same behavior as other major OAuth providers
  • Requires no changes from client applications
  • Unblocks third-party integrations that cannot modify their state format
Real-World Impact
This limitation affects any integration where:
  • Third-party applications set the state parameter and cannot be modified (integration platforms, SaaS connectors, enterprise software)
  • Multi-tenant applications need to encode tenant ID and return URL in state
  • CSRF protection implementations combine security tokens with application state
  • Single Sign-On flows need to preserve original request context
  • Migration projects from other OAuth providers that used pipe delimiters

Critical Blocker: When the state parameter originates from a third-party system outside your control, there is no workaround available. The integration is completely impossible until this is fixed.

Security Note: The state parameter is critical for CSRF protection in OAuth flows. Forcing developers to change their state encoding approach may inadvertently introduce security vulnerabilities if not handled carefully.

Request to Zoho Team

Can this be addressed in a future update?

This is a standards compliance issue that impacts developers integrating with Zoho's API. For those who control their client application, the current implementation forces unnecessary workarounds. For those integrating third-party applications, the situation is worse:

1. Custom development
Refactor code to avoid pipe characters, creating Zoho-specific OAuth handling
2. Third-party integrations
No workaround possible - integration is completely blocked

Users should not be blocked from integrating with Zoho due to non-standard OAuth implementation.

Community Input Requested: Has anyone else encountered this issue? Are there other special characters that cause similar problems with Zoho's OAuth implementation?

    • Sticky Posts

    • Deprecation of SMS-based multi-factor authentication (MFA) mode

      Overview of SMS-based OTP MFA mode The SMS-based OTP MFA method involves the delivery of a one-time password to a user's mobile phone via SMS. The user receives the OTP on their mobile phone and enters it to sign into their account. SMS-based OTPs offer
    • Recent Topics

    • How can I hide "My Requests" and "Marketplace" icon from the side menu

      Hello everybody, We recently started using the new Zoho CRM for Everyone. How can I hide "My Requests" and "Marketplace" from the side menu? We don't use these features at the moment, and I couldn't find a way to disable or remove them. Best regards,
    • Ability to assign Invoice Ownership through Deluge in FSM

      Hi, As part of our process, when a service appointment is completed, we automated the creation of the invoice based on a specific business logic using Deluge. When we do that, the "Owner" of the invoice in Zoho FSM is defaulted to the SuperAdmin. This
    • Right Shift key not sending to Zoho Assist environments

      I'm unable to use Right Shift key in Zoho environments. Zoho environments are Win10. Computer I access from is Win 11. Issue started when I changed to Win 11. Have tried: - Multiple browsers - web client AND desktop client - 3rd party mapping tools to
    • How do you do ticket add ons in Backstage?

      Hi Everyone, If you wanted to have general admin tickets and allow for add ons, like camping, or car or Carbon offset. What would you do? Peace Robin
    • From Zoho CRM to Paper : Design & Print Data Directly using Canvas Print View

      Hello Everyone, We are excited to announce a new addition to your Canvas in Zoho CRM - Print View. Canvas print view helps you transform your custom CRM layouts into print-ready documents, so you can bring your digital data to the physical world with
    • validation rules doesn't work in Blueprint when it is validated using function?

      I have tried to create a validation rule in the deal module. it works if I try to create a deal manually or if I try to update the empty field inside a deal. but when I try to update the field via the blueprint mandatory field, it seems the validation
    • Pull cells from one sheet onto another

      Hello all! I have created an ingredients database where i have pricing and information and i want to pull from that database into a recipe calculator. I want it to pull based on what ingredient I choose. The ingredients database has an idea and i want
    • How can Data Enrichment be automatically triggered when a new Lead is created in Zoho CRM?

      Hi, I have a pipeline where a Lead is created automatically through the Zoho API and I've been trying to look for a way to automatically apply Data Enrichment on this created lead. 1) I did not find any way to do this through the Zoho API; it seems like
    • Emails Failing with “Relaying Issues – Mail Sending Blocked” in ZeptoMail

      Hello ZeptoMail Support Team, We are facing an email delivery issue in our ZeptoMail account where emails are failing with the status “Process failed” and the reason “Relaying issues – Mail sending blocked.” Issue Details Agent Name: mail_agent_iwwa From
    • How does Zoho handle support operations for our EU users?

      Dear Zoho users, We have some news and reminders about how we handle support operations for Zoho users in the EU Data Center. This is part of our broader commitment to ensuring GDPR compliance and providing secure data handling for all users. We'd like
    • Sender Email Configuration Error.

      Hello Team, Hope you are all doing well. We are in the process of creating the Zoho FSM environment in the UAE. When we try to add the sender email address “techsupportuae@stryker.com”, we receive the error message: “Error occurred while sending mail
    • Different Task Layouts for Subtasks

      I was wondering how it would be possible for a subtask to have a different task layout to the parent task.
    • Layout Adjustment.

      Hello Latha, Hope you are doing well. I wanted to check with you about adjusting the layout columns in the Service Report from the backend, as currently there is no capability for us to customize the layout from our end. Below is the output that I am
    • Let us view and export the full price books data from CRM

      I quote out of CRM, some of my clients have specialised pricing for specific products - therefore we use Price Books to manage these special prices. I can only see the breakdown of the products listed in the price book and the specialised pricing for
    • Anyone in Australia using Zoho Books AND has their account with NAB?

      Hi I have an account with both NAB and Suncorp. Suncorp transaction come in the next day however NAB transactions take 4-5 business days to appear. eg: A deposit made today in my Suncorp will be imported into Zoho tomorrow. A deposit made today to the NAB account will be imported maybe Saturday (Friday overnight). I have contacted both Zoho and NAB but noone seems to know why. I was just wondering if anyone else in Australia uses NAB and has this issue (or doesn't) maybe we could compare notes and
    • Zoho Often Lag

      Desk Team, We've noticed that Desk, Creator & other apps seems to lag more these days. We often refresh multiple times.
    • Offer already made- but I withdrew it

      I made an offer letter, but made a mistake on it. I withdrew the offer but now I can't recreate the correct offer. Zoho keeps saying that "A same offer has already been made". I look in the "offers" and there are NO offers (this is the first time I've
    • Importing into the 'file upload' field

      Can you import attachments into the file upload field. I would expect it to work the same way as attachments do, But can't seem to get it to work. Moderation Update: The option to import into File Upload and Image Upload fields has been supported. Read
    • Layout Rules Don't Apply To Blueprints

      Hi Zoho the conditional layout rules for fields and making fields required don't work well with with Blueprints if those same fields are called DURING a Blueprint. Example. I have field A that is used in layout rule. If value of field A is "1" it is supposed to show and make required field B. If the value to field A is "2" it is supposed to show and make required field C. Now I have a Blueprint that says when last stage moves to "Closed," during the transition, the agent must fill out field A. Now
    • Why is the ability Customize Calls module so limited?

      Why can't I add additional sections? why can't I add other field types than the very limited subset that zoho allows? Why can I only add fields to the outbound/inbound call sections and not to the Call Information section?
    • Zoho Desk blank screen

      opened a ticket from my email, zoho desk comes up blank, nothing loads. our receptionist also gets the same thing under her login on her computer. our sales rep also gets same thing on zoho desk at his home on a different computer. I tried clearing cache/history/cookies,
    • Exporting All Custom Functions in ZohoCRM

      Hello, All I've been looking for a way to keep about 30 functions that I have written in Zoho CRM updated in my own repository to use elsewhere in other instances. A github integration would be great, but a way to export all custom functions or any way
    • Optimum CRM setup for new B2B business

      Can some advise the most common way to setup Zoho CRM to handle sales for a B2B company? Specifically in how to handle inbound/outbound emails. I have spent hours researching online and can't seem to find an accepted approach, or even a tutorial. I have
    • filter on sheets mobile (iOS, iPadOS) does not work

      I have this issue on every spreadsheet, whether imported or created natively in Zoho Sheets. I can use on desktop without issue: desktop screenshot on iOS the filter dropdowns are not there and there is no way to add them mobile iPadOS looks the same
    • 【Zoho CRM】商談タブへのデータインポート

      Zoho使用前にエクセルで管理していた商談情報を、Zoho一括管理のため、商談タブにインポートしたいのですが、お客さまの氏名だけが紐づけられませんでした。 「Zoho CRMにインポートする項目を関連付ける」のところが画像のようになっています。 (弊社では、「姓」を「★個人データ名」という項目名に変更し、フルネームを入れて使用しています。) どのようにしたら氏名をインポートできるかご存じの方がいらっしゃいましたら、ご教示いただきたく、よろしくお願いいたします。 (投稿先が間違っていましたらご指
    • Canva Integration

      Hello! As many marketing departments are streamlining their teams, many have begun utilizing Canva for all design mockups and approvals prior to its integration into Marketing automation software. While Zoho Social has this integration already accomplished,
    • Can't edit Segments

      Happening with 2 different Zoho One environments, in different browsers. Please fix.
    • Zoho Sheet for Desktop

      Does Zoho plans to develop a Desktop version of Sheet that installs on the computer like was done with Writer?
    • Transfer ownership of files and folders in My Folders

      People work together as a team to achieve organizational goals and objectives. In an organization, there may be situations when someone leaves unexpectedly or is no longer available. This can put their team in a difficult position, especially if there
    • Consumer Financing

      Does Zoho currently have a payment gateway (such as Stripe, Square, etc) which offers financing for customers? So, let's say the estimate we give the customer is greater than what they can afford at the time, but we can sell the service now, letting them
    • Subform edits don't appear in parent record timeline?

      Is it possible to have subform edits (like add row/delete row) appear in the Timeline for parent records? A user can edit a record, only edit the subform, and it doesn't appear in the timeline. Is there a workaround or way that we can show when a user
    • Zoho CRM - Option to create Follow-Up Task

      When completing a Zoho CRM Task, it would be very helpful if there was an option to "Complete and Create Follow-Up Task" in the pop-up which appears. It could clone the task you are closing and then show it on the screen in edit mode, all the user would
    • Mandatory Field - but only at conversion

      Hello! We use Zoho CRM and there are times where the "Lead Created Date & Time" field isn't populated into a "Contractor" (Account is the default phrase i believe). Most of my lead tracking is based on reading the Lead Created field above, so it's important
    • Zoho CRM for Everyone's NextGen UI Gets an Upgrade

      Hello Everyone We've made improvements to Zoho CRM for Everyone's Nextgen UI. These changes are the result of valuable feedback from you where we’ve focused on improving usability, providing wider screen space, and making navigation smoother so everything
    • File Upload field automatically replaces spaces with underscores – support experience

      Hi everyone, I want to share my recent experience regarding the File Upload field behavior in Zoho Creator and my interaction with the Zoho support team. When a user uploads a file, the system automatically renames the document by replacing spaces in
    • Deluge function to copy parent record file upload field to child record file upload field

      I'm stuck trying to write a deluge function that is triggered via automation in child record "Appointments," confirms if a file is in file upload "Report" field of parent "Contacts" record via Contacts lookup field "Contact_Name". If no file is in parent
    • Zoho Books Sandbox environment

      Hello. Is there a free sandbox environment for the developers using Zoho Books API? I am working on the Zoho Books add-on and currently not ready to buy a premium service - maybe later when my add-on will start to bring money. Right now I just need a
    • Make panel configuration interface wider

      Hi there, The same way you changed the custom function editor's interface wider, it would be nice to be able to edit panels in pages using the full width of the screen rather than the currently max-width: 1368px. Is there a reason for having the configuration panel not taking the full width? Its impossible at this width to edit panels that have a lot of elements. Please change it to 100% so we can better edit the layouts. Thanks! B.
    • Image Compression Options

      Much better if we have level of options to compress the image [20%, 40%...] We are dealing with service reports daily that has before and after photos (image field)- the file size too large and one thing, the current limit is 10mb or 15mb for report
    • Cannot get code to work with v2.mergeAndStore!

      Please can someone help me pass subform items into a repeating mail merge table row using v2.mergeAndStore? I have a mail merge template created in Writer and stored in Workdrive. This template is referenced by a custom CRM function which merges all of
    • Next Page