Catch-all and forwarding issues...

Catch-all and forwarding issues...

I am currently trying to set up a forwarding service for a catch-all address at the domain I connected with Zoho. A little background:

I have two domains. One is handled by Google Apps. The other was - until earlier today - when I migrated it to Zoho. My plan is to make [anything]@[domain2.com] forward to [my.main.email]@[domain1.com].

The problem is, I appear to have everything configured correctly - with the forwarding addresses verified, and 'delete Zoho Mail's copy' checked. The catch-all feature seems to be working, but those messages won't forward. Messages sent directly to [admin]@[domain2.com] will. ALSO - I have 'Delete Zoho Mail's copy' checked, but the messages remain in the inbox.

Maybe there's an easier way to do what I want? If I can successfully set this up, I intend to leave Google completely and bring domain1 over here too!

EDITED - one of the problems I was having was due a stupid mistake of my own.