How do I move a closed task to a different task list?

At the end of the day we need to print all of the tasks that were closed that day. After the tasks are printed, I would like to move them to a different Task List so it is clear they don't need to be printed again.

Once a Task is closed, the box next to the task that you can check when it's open (to move, change priority, etc) is gone. I need that box back or some other way to move the completed task. How?