Bug: OAuth 2.0 State Parameter fails with Pipe Delimiters (RFC 6749 Non-Compliance)

Bug: OAuth 2.0 State Parameter fails with Pipe Delimiters (RFC 6749 Non-Compliance)

I've discovered a bug in how Zoho's API Console handles the OAuth 2.0 authorization flow when the state parameter contains pipe characters (|), and I'm hoping the Zoho team can address this in a future update.
The Issue
Zoho's OAuth 2.0 implementation for server-based client applications uses the standard authorization endpoint:
https://accounts.zoho.com/oauth/v2/auth?response_type=code
&client_id=<client_id>
&scope=<scope>
&redirect_uri=<redirect_uri>
&access_type=offline
&state=<state_value>
While Zoho's documentation does not explicitly list the state parameter, it is a standard part of the OAuth 2.0 specification (RFC 6749 Section 4.1.1) and is widely used for CSRF protection and maintaining application state through the authorization flow.
However, when the state parameter contains pipe characters (|), Zoho's authorization server fails to process the request correctly, preventing users from authorizing the connection. This occurs whether the pipe characters are URL-encoded (%7C) or left unencoded.
The Problem
The pipe character is a standard delimiter in multi-part state values, particularly when passing a combination of a CSRF token and a return URL. This behavior—failing on both encoded and unencoded pipe characters—is often indicative of overly restrictive input validation or a "leaky" WAF/Proxy layer that decodes parameters before the application logic can handle them.
State Value As Sent in URL Result
abc123xyz state=abc123xyz ✓ Works correctly
session_12345 state=session_12345 ✓ Works correctly
user|action|timestamp state=user|action|timestamp
(unencoded pipes)
✗ Authorization fails
user|action|timestamp state=user%7Caction%7Ctimestamp
(URL-encoded pipes)
✗ Authorization fails
user:action:timestamp state=user%3Aaction%3Atimestamp ? Not tested
Note: Pipe characters cause failures whether URL-encoded or not. Other special characters/delimiters have not been tested and may or may not exhibit similar issues.
RFC 6749 Compliance Issue
Section 4.1.1 - Authorization Request:
"state: RECOMMENDED. An opaque value used by the client to maintain state between the request and callback."
Section 4.1.2 - Authorization Response:
"state: REQUIRED if the 'state' parameter was present in the client authorization request. The exact value received from the client."
The RFC explicitly defines the state parameter as an opaque value. This means:
  • The Authorization Server should not be looking "inside" or parsing the string at all
  • The state value must pass through the authorization process unchanged
  • Any URL-encoded characters should be handled transparently
  • The exact value received must be returned to the client in the redirect
Key Point: By definition, an "opaque" parameter means the authorization server must treat it as a data blob—accepting it, storing it, and returning it without any interpretation or transformation.
Current Behavior vs Expected Behavior
Current Behavior Expected Behavior (Per RFC 6749)
1. Client sends: state=user|action|123
(or state=user%7Caction%7C123)
2. Zoho fails to parse the state parameter
3. Authorization server returns HTTP 400 Bad Request
4. User cannot authorize the connection
1. Client sends: state=user|action|123

2. Zoho treats state as opaque data blob
3. User authorizes the connection
4. Redirect includes the exact value received:
state=user|action|123
(or consistently encoded as sent)
The Current Workaround (Suboptimal)
Important: The workarounds below only apply if you have control over the client application generating the OAuth request. If you're integrating with a third-party application that sets the state parameter (e.g., integration platforms, SaaS tools, enterprise software), you have no ability to modify the state value and therefore no workaround is available. You are completely blocked from completing the OAuth flow.
For developers who do control the client application, you must avoid pipe characters entirely:
// Instead of using pipes as delimiters:
state = csrf_token + "|" + user_id + "|" + redirect_path;
// ❌ This breaks Zoho's authorization flow

// Developers must use alternative approaches:
state = csrf_token + "_SEP_" + user_id + "_SEP_" + redirect_path;
// or
state = base64_encode(json_encode({"csrf": token, "user": id, "path": path}));
// or
state = csrf_token; // Store other data server-side keyed by CSRF token
Problems with these workarounds:
  • Requires refactoring existing codebases that use pipe delimiters
  • Base64 encoding increases state parameter length significantly, risking URL length limits (particularly in older browsers and some enterprise proxies which enforce ~2000 character limits)
  • Server-side storage approach adds complexity, database overhead, and potential race conditions
  • Inconsistent with how the same code works with other OAuth providers (Google, Microsoft, etc.)
  • Developers may not discover this issue until production deployment
  • Custom delimiters (like _SEP_) are non-standard and may conflict with actual data values
What Should Happen Instead
Proposed Solution:
Zoho's authorization server should properly handle URL-encoded pipe characters (%7C) in the state parameter, as required by RFC 6749. The state value must be treated as an opaque data blob.
Technical Requirement: Treat state as a Data Blob
1. Input Accept %7C (and other encoded characters) as valid parts of the query string without triggering validation errors or WAF rules
2. Persistence Store the string exactly as received during the user's login/consent session—do not decode, parse, or transform
3. Output Append the exact string back to the redirect_uri without additional transformations that might strip or corrupt the delimiters
This approach:
  • Complies with RFC 6749's requirement to return "the exact value received"
  • Follows the same behavior as other major OAuth providers
  • Requires no changes from client applications
  • Unblocks third-party integrations that cannot modify their state format
Real-World Impact
This limitation affects any integration where:
  • Third-party applications set the state parameter and cannot be modified (integration platforms, SaaS connectors, enterprise software)
  • Multi-tenant applications need to encode tenant ID and return URL in state
  • CSRF protection implementations combine security tokens with application state
  • Single Sign-On flows need to preserve original request context
  • Migration projects from other OAuth providers that used pipe delimiters

Critical Blocker: When the state parameter originates from a third-party system outside your control, there is no workaround available. The integration is completely impossible until this is fixed.

Security Note: The state parameter is critical for CSRF protection in OAuth flows. Forcing developers to change their state encoding approach may inadvertently introduce security vulnerabilities if not handled carefully.

Request to Zoho Team

Can this be addressed in a future update?

This is a standards compliance issue that impacts developers integrating with Zoho's API. For those who control their client application, the current implementation forces unnecessary workarounds. For those integrating third-party applications, the situation is worse:

1. Custom development
Refactor code to avoid pipe characters, creating Zoho-specific OAuth handling
2. Third-party integrations
No workaround possible - integration is completely blocked

Users should not be blocked from integrating with Zoho due to non-standard OAuth implementation.

Community Input Requested: Has anyone else encountered this issue? Are there other special characters that cause similar problems with Zoho's OAuth implementation?

    • Sticky Posts

    • Deprecation of SMS-based multi-factor authentication (MFA) mode

      Overview of SMS-based OTP MFA mode The SMS-based OTP MFA method involves the delivery of a one-time password to a user's mobile phone via SMS. The user receives the OTP on their mobile phone and enters it to sign into their account. SMS-based OTPs offer
    • Recent Topics

    • Enhance Zoho One Conditional Assignment to Fully Reassign App Settings When Changing Departments

      Hi Zoho Team, We’d like to submit a feature request regarding the current behavior of Zoho One’s conditional assignment logic when moving a user between departments. 🔧 Current Limitation As it stands, Zoho One’s conditional assignment does not remove
    • Ability to Filter Alias Mailboxes in Zoho Recruit

      Dear Zoho Recruit Team, I hope you are doing well. We would like to request a feature enhancement regarding the handling of alias mailboxes in Zoho Recruit. Currently, when we connect an alias mailbox (e.g., jobs@domain.com) from our Zoho One account
    • Automatic Department and Employee Sync Between Zoho One and Zoho People

      Dear Zoho Support, I'm writing to propose a valuable feature request that would streamline data management and improve user experience within the Zoho ecosystem: automatic synchronization between departments and employees in Zoho One and Zoho People.
    • Prefered Bin Missing in android APP

      Andoroid app dosent show preferred bin in the picklist. The workaround support reccomend is to use the computre to create the picklist. it shuld be information to be shown aas basic for the pciker.
    • Open Sans Font in Zoho Books is not Open Sans.

      Font choice in customising PDF Templates is very limited, we cannot upload custom fonts, and to make things worse, the font names are not accurate. I selected Open Sans, and thought the system was bugging, but no, Open Sans is not Open Sans. The real
    • Function #1: Convert an accepted Estimate to Sales Order automatically in Zoho Books

      As you’re aware, Zoho Books provides a default option to have the estimates automatically converted to invoices once your customer accepts them. Many of you wanted a similar option for sales orders, so here’s a workflow that converts accepted estimates
    • Reusable Jira Connection for Multiple Zoho Projects Imports

      Hello Zoho Projects Team, We would like to raise a concern and submit a feature request regarding the Jira → Zoho Projects migration process, specifically around how Jira connections are handled. Current Behavior: When setting up a Jira connection for
    • Zoho invoice doesn't support Arabic language

      I added a clause in the terms & conditions section in Arabic but it doesn't appear when I sent or print it.
    • Recurring Invoice Placeholder Not Updating Billing Period

      Hi, I’m using Zoho Invoice Free and want the billing period to update automatically in recurring invoices. In Item Description I tried: Billing Period: %(m-6)% %(y)% to %(m-1)% %(y)% but even if the invoice date is in 2026, it still shows the period based
    • Related list Mobile Device

      Hello, We use an the Zoho creator application to make reports linked to Accounts. On the computer: it's easy to go the Account and see all the created reports in the related list below On iPad/Phone ZOHO CRM APP: we cannot see the reports on those accounts
    • Can't update the company address in zoho invoice

      Dear Sir/Madam, I want to update the company address in Zoho Invoice but failed. It popped out a sentence "Invalid value passed for Website". Please advice how to solve this problem. Thank you.
    • Is there a plan to allow for the hierarchical organization of Customers / Companies in Zoho Billing?

      We have a few customers who have organizational structures that we haven't quite found a way to deal with in Zoho Billing. In CRM, these sub-companies (or subsidiaries or whatever you want to call them) all have another CRM account as the parent account.
    • 【Zoho CRM】作業リスト機能リリースのお知らせ

      ユーザーの皆さま、こんにちは。コミュニティチームの藤澤です。 今回は「Zoho CRM アップデート情報」の中から、作業リスト機能リリースのお知らせ情報をご紹介します。 目次 作業リスト機能 概要 機能① 自分の未完了の活動 機能② 処理待ち 機能③ 自分の作業リスト 作業リスト機能 概要 営業チームでは、CRM内に業務やデータが分散しているため、管理が煩雑になりがちです。この断片化は、機会の見逃しや生産性の低下につながります。 作業リスト機能は、タブを横断する業務項目をひとつのカスタマイズ可能なダッシュボードに集約し、業務を効率的に管理できるようにします。
    • SalesIQとPageSenseの利用について

      初めての投稿で場違いだったらすいません。 弊社ではSalesIQを運用しているのですが、追加でPageSenseの導入もしたいと現場からの声があります。 両サービスともクッキー同意バナーが必要なサービスなのですが 弊社では同意無しに情報はとりませんという方針なので 2つ入れると2つバナーを出す必要がでてきます・・・ 両サービスを運用されてる方があれば運用状況とか教えてほしいです。 PageSenseについては詳細まで機能を理解してないなかでの質問です。
    • Parent-Child Tickets using API or Deluge

      Hi Everyone, We are looking at the parent-child ticketing features in Zoho Desk. We want to be able to create a parent ticket at customer level and nest child tickets underneath. The issue we are facing is to be able to automate this. I'm checking the
    • Closing connected ticket after closing WA conversation

      Hi, At the moment, once someone sends a message to our WA number, a corresponding ticket is automatically created. After the question is answered, our support department closes the chat/conversation. However, after that, the connected ticket is still
    • Note sync turn off

      Hi, Is it possible to turn off notes sync between task notes and the parent module? (Account/Deal)
    • Basic Plan Active but Survey Creation Still Limited to 3 Surveys

      I have an active Basic (Monthly) subscription (valid period: Dec 24, 2025 – Jan 24, 2026), but the system still limits survey creation to only 3 surveys, which matches Free plan behavior. The subscription appears active in Portal Information, however
    • 2025 in Review: Powering Field Services Forward—One Feature at a Time

      As 2025 draws to a close, it’s time to pause and reflect on a year of meaningful progress at Zoho FSM. This year was all about listening closely to our customers and partners, building with purpose, and continuously improving the way field service teams
    • API Support for Creating Invoices with Batch-Tracked Items

      Hi Zoho Community, I am working on an integration where we create invoices in ERPNext and push them to Zoho Books. I need to send batch-tracked items (batch numbers) when creating invoices. I could not find any reference in the Zoho Books API documentation.
    • New to automation - please help

      Hi there! We are new to automations in Zoho. We built out one automation campaign and it seems to be firing off for some people but others not. Please advise what's the best practice or if anything we should tweak. Thank you so much!
    • Unable to Create Zoho Booking via the Book Appointment API

      Its giving the below error {     "response": {         "errormessage": "Error setting value for the variable:customer_details\n null",         "status": "Error"     } } Request: POST Url: https://www.zohoapis.in/bookings/v1/json/appointment attached Zoho-oauthtoken
    • Task Details on task template

      When creating a task template in settings that task details seem to be missing. Is it not possible to set the details of a task, such as the priority, type, reminder settings, and custom field values?
    • Building Toppings #3 -Testing and publishing Bigin toppings

      Hey Biginners! In previous forum posts, we discussed what a Bigin topping is and explored the Bigin Developer Console's features. In this post, we're going to create a topping from scratch and discuss how to test and publish it. Our topping will automate
    • markdown files?

      How can I import a markdown file into a note?
    • Mail to Zoho Notebook

      In the Instuctiosn I faound as email add@notebook.app In my account I see add@eu.notebook.app What is correct please
    • Auto-Invite Users to Portals in Zoho CRM based on Conditions

      Hello Everyone, You can now automate portal invitations in Zoho CRM with the new Auto-Invite users feature in Portal management. No more manually enabling portal access one by one. With this enhancement, you can automatically send invites for users to
    • Growth You can Count On: Zoho Billing's 2025 Journey

      As we wrap up 2025, we’re reflecting on a year rooted in steady progress and meaningful growth for Zoho Billing. Every enhancement we have introduced was built to support scalable and reliable billing growth for your business. From launching the Enterprise
    • Need help with creating workflow with Bigin and Clickup

      Can you please help me with this? I am trying to create a workflow in Zoho Flow wherein a bigin Pipeline deal moves to Decision Closing, it will create a task and subtasks in Clickup, under the condition/filter that the Deal name contains the word Social
    • [Webinar] Automate generation of wills, trusts, POAs, and other estate planning documents with Zoho Writer

      Managing the lifecycle of the estate planning documents such as wills, trusts, and POAs, from client intake to final storage, can be complex and time-consuming. Join our live webinar to learn how Zoho Writer transforms this process by automating document
    • Create / Update Rule in TeamInbox when record is updated in ZohoCRM using flow?

      I'm currently evaluating options and trying to work out if the possible scenario is possible; If a record in ZohoCRM is updated, take 2 of the fields from that - lets call them 'OrderRef' and 'OrderTo'. Using flow, if a record is added or updated, add
    • Plans to allow more columns of monitoring, and monitoring not only your own channels?

      Are their any plans to allow more columns of monitoring, and monitoring not only your own channels? Here's why - I'm sure I'm not alone in that we sell other brands products, so not only am I interested in my own brand social channels, but also the social
    • Unwrapping the best practices for the Zoho Desk mobile app: Part 1

      In focus: Empowering the field and frontline customer support representatives Imagine having to carry your computer everywhere to respond to customers, handle escalations, and update your process. This series presents you with efficient tips to handle
    • dealing with post dated cheques

      Hi, can you help me please the best way to deal with this We sell an item of three months duration that is paid for with post dated cheques in monthly stages example - item is sold £3000 Cheque 1 is for £1000 due at time of sale (say Sept) cheque 2 is dated 25th of next month (Oct) cheque 3 is dated 25th of next month +1 (Nov) Now, with invoice number one it's simple - i send a standard invoice as usual But with the other two here's what i want zoho to do next month i want it to send an invoice on
    • Is there a way to sell in a practical method multiple subscriptions of the same product? i.e. domain names

      In evaluating Zoho Billing, a hurdle to adopting it is that Zoho Billing does not seem designed to support businesses that sell multiple subscriptions of the same product. In our case, we need to sell and manage several domain names per client. Am I right
    • Bug Report: "Name A-Z" sorting fails when Note titles start with an Emoji

      Hello, I recently migrated from Evernote (~2600 notes across 23 notebooks). I use emojis at the start of my note titles for visual organization. The Issue: When I set the view to Sort by: Name (A to Z), the sorting logic breaks for any note starting with
    • Copy & Paste not working

      I could create and save 10 new documents but when I go to copy and paste content (just text) into them, only 1 of 10 would save the content. It would appear to save the content but when I go back into the documents, they are empty.
    • Currency for Petty Cash

      Currencies for Petty Cash should be available
    • editing/applying online payments

      We have customers who pay part or all of an invoice and then cancel their service and want the payment as a credit to future work. It would be ideal if we could make it an excess payment and then void the invoice. I can't make it an excess payment because
    • Contacts per department

      Hello, Is it possible to limit Contacts to a Department? Thanks
    • Next Page