"group" doesn't seem to be responding as I'm expecting

Hi,

I'm trying to figure out why the group setting isn't working. Here is what I have setup for the group:

I have 2 users setup - andy@ and steve@

The groups email is hello@ .

I sent a test email from my gmail to hello@ . The email comes in fine to both the andy@ and steve@ emails.

I reply, and both my @gmail account gets the reply (as expected), and steve@ also gets it.

steve@ then replies, and my @gmail gets the reply, but I don't on andy@.

It seems that steve is getting all the back and forth emails, but I seem to be missing any replies from him

Do I need to configure anything else? It seems like the perfect tool for us otherwise :)

Cheers

Andy