Bug: OAuth 2.0 State Parameter fails with Pipe Delimiters (RFC 6749 Non-Compliance)

Bug: OAuth 2.0 State Parameter fails with Pipe Delimiters (RFC 6749 Non-Compliance)

I've discovered a bug in how Zoho's API Console handles the OAuth 2.0 authorization flow when the state parameter contains pipe characters (|), and I'm hoping the Zoho team can address this in a future update.
The Issue
Zoho's OAuth 2.0 implementation for server-based client applications uses the standard authorization endpoint:
https://accounts.zoho.com/oauth/v2/auth?response_type=code
&client_id=<client_id>
&scope=<scope>
&redirect_uri=<redirect_uri>
&access_type=offline
&state=<state_value>
While Zoho's documentation does not explicitly list the state parameter, it is a standard part of the OAuth 2.0 specification (RFC 6749 Section 4.1.1) and is widely used for CSRF protection and maintaining application state through the authorization flow.
However, when the state parameter contains pipe characters (|), Zoho's authorization server fails to process the request correctly, preventing users from authorizing the connection. This occurs whether the pipe characters are URL-encoded (%7C) or left unencoded.
The Problem
The pipe character is a standard delimiter in multi-part state values, particularly when passing a combination of a CSRF token and a return URL. This behavior—failing on both encoded and unencoded pipe characters—is often indicative of overly restrictive input validation or a "leaky" WAF/Proxy layer that decodes parameters before the application logic can handle them.
State Value As Sent in URL Result
abc123xyz state=abc123xyz ✓ Works correctly
session_12345 state=session_12345 ✓ Works correctly
user|action|timestamp state=user|action|timestamp
(unencoded pipes)
✗ Authorization fails
user|action|timestamp state=user%7Caction%7Ctimestamp
(URL-encoded pipes)
✗ Authorization fails
user:action:timestamp state=user%3Aaction%3Atimestamp ? Not tested
Note: Pipe characters cause failures whether URL-encoded or not. Other special characters/delimiters have not been tested and may or may not exhibit similar issues.
RFC 6749 Compliance Issue
Section 4.1.1 - Authorization Request:
"state: RECOMMENDED. An opaque value used by the client to maintain state between the request and callback."
Section 4.1.2 - Authorization Response:
"state: REQUIRED if the 'state' parameter was present in the client authorization request. The exact value received from the client."
The RFC explicitly defines the state parameter as an opaque value. This means:
  • The Authorization Server should not be looking "inside" or parsing the string at all
  • The state value must pass through the authorization process unchanged
  • Any URL-encoded characters should be handled transparently
  • The exact value received must be returned to the client in the redirect
Key Point: By definition, an "opaque" parameter means the authorization server must treat it as a data blob—accepting it, storing it, and returning it without any interpretation or transformation.
Current Behavior vs Expected Behavior
Current Behavior Expected Behavior (Per RFC 6749)
1. Client sends: state=user|action|123
(or state=user%7Caction%7C123)
2. Zoho fails to parse the state parameter
3. Authorization server returns HTTP 400 Bad Request
4. User cannot authorize the connection
1. Client sends: state=user|action|123

2. Zoho treats state as opaque data blob
3. User authorizes the connection
4. Redirect includes the exact value received:
state=user|action|123
(or consistently encoded as sent)
The Current Workaround (Suboptimal)
Important: The workarounds below only apply if you have control over the client application generating the OAuth request. If you're integrating with a third-party application that sets the state parameter (e.g., integration platforms, SaaS tools, enterprise software), you have no ability to modify the state value and therefore no workaround is available. You are completely blocked from completing the OAuth flow.
For developers who do control the client application, you must avoid pipe characters entirely:
// Instead of using pipes as delimiters:
state = csrf_token + "|" + user_id + "|" + redirect_path;
// ❌ This breaks Zoho's authorization flow

// Developers must use alternative approaches:
state = csrf_token + "_SEP_" + user_id + "_SEP_" + redirect_path;
// or
state = base64_encode(json_encode({"csrf": token, "user": id, "path": path}));
// or
state = csrf_token; // Store other data server-side keyed by CSRF token
Problems with these workarounds:
  • Requires refactoring existing codebases that use pipe delimiters
  • Base64 encoding increases state parameter length significantly, risking URL length limits (particularly in older browsers and some enterprise proxies which enforce ~2000 character limits)
  • Server-side storage approach adds complexity, database overhead, and potential race conditions
  • Inconsistent with how the same code works with other OAuth providers (Google, Microsoft, etc.)
  • Developers may not discover this issue until production deployment
  • Custom delimiters (like _SEP_) are non-standard and may conflict with actual data values
What Should Happen Instead
Proposed Solution:
Zoho's authorization server should properly handle URL-encoded pipe characters (%7C) in the state parameter, as required by RFC 6749. The state value must be treated as an opaque data blob.
Technical Requirement: Treat state as a Data Blob
1. Input Accept %7C (and other encoded characters) as valid parts of the query string without triggering validation errors or WAF rules
2. Persistence Store the string exactly as received during the user's login/consent session—do not decode, parse, or transform
3. Output Append the exact string back to the redirect_uri without additional transformations that might strip or corrupt the delimiters
This approach:
  • Complies with RFC 6749's requirement to return "the exact value received"
  • Follows the same behavior as other major OAuth providers
  • Requires no changes from client applications
  • Unblocks third-party integrations that cannot modify their state format
Real-World Impact
This limitation affects any integration where:
  • Third-party applications set the state parameter and cannot be modified (integration platforms, SaaS connectors, enterprise software)
  • Multi-tenant applications need to encode tenant ID and return URL in state
  • CSRF protection implementations combine security tokens with application state
  • Single Sign-On flows need to preserve original request context
  • Migration projects from other OAuth providers that used pipe delimiters

Critical Blocker: When the state parameter originates from a third-party system outside your control, there is no workaround available. The integration is completely impossible until this is fixed.

Security Note: The state parameter is critical for CSRF protection in OAuth flows. Forcing developers to change their state encoding approach may inadvertently introduce security vulnerabilities if not handled carefully.

Request to Zoho Team

Can this be addressed in a future update?

This is a standards compliance issue that impacts developers integrating with Zoho's API. For those who control their client application, the current implementation forces unnecessary workarounds. For those integrating third-party applications, the situation is worse:

1. Custom development
Refactor code to avoid pipe characters, creating Zoho-specific OAuth handling
2. Third-party integrations
No workaround possible - integration is completely blocked

Users should not be blocked from integrating with Zoho due to non-standard OAuth implementation.

Community Input Requested: Has anyone else encountered this issue? Are there other special characters that cause similar problems with Zoho's OAuth implementation?

    • Sticky Posts

    • Deprecation of SMS-based multi-factor authentication (MFA) mode

      Overview of SMS-based OTP MFA mode The SMS-based OTP MFA method involves the delivery of a one-time password to a user's mobile phone via SMS. The user receives the OTP on their mobile phone and enters it to sign into their account. SMS-based OTPs offer
    • Recent Topics

    • DKIM cannot be enabled for the domain as no verified default selector present

      Can't get the DKIM working. May you please check my account (nksy.us) to see what's wrong?
    • Collections Management: #3 Tackling Payment Failures

      Sam refreshed the dashboard. "Payment failed". Same customer. Same subscription. This is happening for the third time. He sends a usual email: "Your renewal payment failed again. Could you please check and retry?" A couple of days passed, and there was
    • How do I increase the email attachment size in Zoho CRM ?

      It looks like I'm limited to 10MB when sending an attachment using the email widget on a record in Zoho CRM. Is there a way to increase the size? Or can I use some other tool? From what I'm reading online, I'm maxed out at 10MB. Any insight would be greatly
    • Zoho sign and creator error message {"code":9043,"error_param":"Checked by","message":"Extra key found","status":"failure"}

      Good day, I receive the error message: {"code":9043,"error_param":"Checked by","message":"Extra key found","status":"failure"} when running below code from creator to sign, void TestForSign(int ID) { //Fetch Template Details (Optional, for dynamic mapping)
    • Download a writer template as .docx instead of .pdf.

      I have been trying to implement a feature to download a writer template as a .docx and got it working partly but it isn't good. Earlier I checked our code and I saw openurl("https://crm.zoho.com/crm/org121314/specific/Template.do?action=print&step=pdfPreview&id="
    • Allow the usage of Multi-Select fields as the primary field on "Layout Rules"

      We want to force our users to enter some explanation strings when a multi-select field has been utilized. I can't understand the reason for the usage restriction of Multi-Select fields as a primary field. This is a simple "Display hidden mandatory field
    • Extract Archived Projects using Zoho Projects API

      In my organization we archive the projects when they are already completed, charged, invoiced, so that only those that are still pending process remain active. I need to access all projects (active and archived) from an external system, but the API v3
    • Ask the Experts: Five-hour live Q&A session with Zoho WorkDrive product experts

      Have questions about WorkDrive 5.0? Let’s talk! We recently launched Zoho WorkDrive 5.0, packed with powerful updates to help your team work smarter, stay secure, and get more value from your business content. From content-centric workflows and AI-powered
    • File upload support for subforms

      Dear All, Subforms help you add and track data related to your CRM records. We've always supported most of the commonly used field types in subforms, so as to cater to your business requirements. Now we're happy to extend support to file upload fields.
    • Circular record relationship in CRM

      Given there is a lookup in custom module Transactions creating a related list on the chosen Contact record. I. e. a lookup field on Transactions module points to Contacts. The related list on a Contact record can thus have have many transaction records.
    • Is it possible to pull the Zoho desk data into Zoho analytics in real time

      Hi - I am looking to add more dashboards and reports of Zoho Desk in analytics. I see there is a schedule to pull the data into analytics, but I'm wondering if there is an option to pull the data in real time instead of a specific interval?
    • How to set value of dropdown field to variable

      For the life of me, I can't figure out why the following code won't set input.status to the previousSelection. Steps to reproduce: 1. Click input.complete 2. input.status dropdown updates from '1-Backlog' to '4-Done' 3. Click input.complete again to deselect
    • [Product Update] TimeSheets module is now renamed as Time Logs in Zoho Projects.

      Dear Zoho Analytics customers, As part of the ongoing enhancements in Zoho Projects, the Timesheets module has been renamed to Time Logs. However, the module name will continue to be displayed as Timesheets in Zoho Analytics until the relevant APIs are
    • [WEBINAR][MEA] Learn how to control your inventory and multi-channel sales with the Zoho Inventory & Zoho Books integration

      Hello there, We are hosting an exclusive live webinar tailored for businesses across the Middle East and African countries, where you'll learn how to take full control of your inventory and multi-channel sales while keeping your accounting perfectly in
    • Less clicks, more connection – the usability edge of Zoho Desk

      Imagine joining a new workplace, eager to prove your skills, partner with peers, learn new tools, and build a strong foundation for your career. The standards you've set could drive pressure into your head. You now discover the organization is using Zoho
    • Tip #3 Automating total item weight calculation for your sales orders in Zoho Inventory

      Hello, Hope the day is treating you well. Last week, we saw how we could automate the calculation of total shipping charges from numerous shipments for your sales orders and invoices. This week, we will see how you can automate the calculation of total item weight for your sales orders.  How does this work? First, you are required to capture the weight of all your items using a custom field. And when you create a sales order, you can either have the system display the individual weights for you or
    • Why Format section gets disabled when we create Merge Template over PDF

      I need some assistance I have a Client who is going to give certificates to users who passes his exam. So, I am using mail merge but in ZOHO writer after I upload the PDF and create merge Template over PDF the format Section gets disabled. My problem
    • How to calculate separate totals for Product Line Items filtered by category in Quotes?

      Hello! I'm working with Quotes in Zoho CRM and need help calculating conditional totals for line items. Current setup: I have two tables in my Quote template (Zoho Writer), both displaying Quoted Line Items Table 1 (top): Shows all products where Product
    • Zoho Desk API Documentation missing a required field

      We are trying to create a section using this information. Even after preparing everything based on that page, we still get an error. The error we get is this: {"errorCode":"INVALID_DATA","message":"The data is invalid due to validation restrictions","errors":[{"fieldName":"/translations","errorType":"missing","errorMessage":""}]}
    • Fetch Subform values through a lookup of a lookup

      Hi, I'm having an issue fetching the values of a subform through a lookup field through another lookup field. The code works perfectly to show me the subform row ID, but the second I try to get any readable data, it says "Error occurred. Please contact
    • Turn Decision Box to a button

      Dear all, I need your help on CSS to turn a Decision Box to a Button. I have a Decision Box like: Turn on/off to refresh the information. (on User Input, either True or False, will refresh the information) Now I want to simulate to treat it like a Refresh
    • Emails not being received from a particular domain

      Cannot receive any emails sent from atco.com Domain is in the spam whitelist so should be no reason for it not to be coming through. Have filed a ticket and besides a generic response of we are looking at it - it seems there is no actual support workers
    • Stock Count

      The stock count is a nice new feature, but we cannot figure out how to: 1. Use it without assigning to a person, we have a team or one of multiple do stock counts as do most any company. 2. Add any extra fields to what the "counter" sees. The most important
    • Send Whatsapp message from Whatsapp template with custom variables

      Hi, I'm trying to do some basic integration for sending WhatsApp messages from Zoho CRM using Zoho Desk whatsapp templates. When creating new whatsapp template in Zoho Desk we can choose ticket related fields as variables but it's not clear how to use
    • Outgoing blocked: Unusual activity detected.

      I just made payment for my Zohomail Today and have been debited so i will like to be Unblocked because this is what it says (Outgoing blocked: Unusual activity detected) Thank you i await your swift responses
    • Integrating with My Own Application and ZOHO CRM Simultaneously

      I have my own WhatsApp bot that uses my WhatsApp business account. I want to use the same phone number to integrate with ZOHO as well. What is the recommended way to do that? Should I integrate my application with ZOHO, forwarding messages whenever the
    • Account for Cryptocurrency Holdings in Zoho Books/Custom Currencies?

      Hello, I've recently started using Zoho to run my small business and I've really been enjoying all of its features. However, I've been struggling to find a way to account for cryptocurrencies in Zoho Books. My company mines a Cryptocurrency token called
    • Transferring CRM Attachments to Workdrive

      relatedrecords = zoho.crm.getRelatedRecords("Attachments","Conditions",conId); attachid = List(); for each ele in relatedrecords { attachementId = ele.get("id"); attachid.add(attachementId); } for each ele in attachid { counter = 1; downloadFile = invokeurl [ url: "https://www.zohoapis.com/crm/v2/Conditions/" + conId + "/Attachments/" + ele type: GET connection : "work_drive" ]; resp2 = zoho.crm.attachFile("Deals",dealId,downloadFile); resp3 = zoho.workdrive.uploadFile(downloadFile, dealWD, "PlaceHolder"+counter+"",
    • New Customization options in the module builder: Quick Create and Detail view

      Hello everyone, We have introduced two new components to the module builder: Quick create and Detail view. The Quick Create Component It is a mini form used to create a record and associate it to the parent record from a lookup field. For example, if you have a Deals lookup in the Contacts module, then you can associate existing deals or create a deal and associate it with the contact. You can customize this Quick Create form by adding standard as well as custom fields. There is no limit to the number
    • unblock my zoho mail account. outlines@zoho.com

      please unblock my zoho mail account, outlines@zoho.com
    • SMTP email sending problem

      Hello, I've sent emails before, but you haven't responded. Please respond. My work is being disrupted. I can't send emails via SMTP. Initially, there were no problems, but now I'm constantly receiving 550 bounce errors. I can't use the service I paid
    • Mailk got blocked / Inquiry About Email Sending Limits and Upgrade Options

      Dear Zoho Support Team, My name is Kamr Elsayed I created this account to use for applying for vocational training in Germany. As part of this process, I send multiple emails to different companies. However, after sending only 8 emails today, I received
    • Forwarder

      Hi, I tried to add a forwarder from which emails are sent to my main zoho account email . However, it asks me for a code that should be received at the forwarder email, which is still not activated to send to my zoho emial account. So how can I get the
    • No chat option

      Chat option is not supported.
    • Direct “Add to Google Calendar” Option in Zoho Meeting

      Hello Zoho Meeting Team, Hope you are doing well. We would like to request an enhancement related to the “Add to Calendar” functionality in Zoho Meeting. Currently, when we open Zoho Meeting and view our meetings under My Calendar, there is an Add to
    • DKIM cannot be enabled for the domain as no verified default selector present

      Hi Support Team, For Domain DKIM record trying to enable status. but showing error "DKIM cannot be enabled for the domain as no verified default selector present" So, please resolve the issue. Thank you.
    • unable to send message reason 554 5.1.8 Email outgoing blocked

      unable to send message reason 554 5.1.8 Email outgoing blocked
    • I can't log in to my account on Thunderbird

      I've just had to rebuild my PC (calamitous mess from Microsoft with Win10/Win 11 'upgrade' - they confirmed I had to start with a new build). I have used Zoho mail for years via Mozilla Thunderbird, but now I've had to download the latest version of TBird,
    • Should I Use DMARC?

      When I configure Zoho Mail's DMARC settings, it's mandatory to fill in the RUA and RUF (Aggregate notification email address*, Forensic notification email address*) addresses. When we enter an email address in these fields, we receive reports from the
    • Introducing Profile Summary: Faster Candidate Insights with Zia

      We’re excited to launch Profile Summary, a powerful new feature in Zoho Recruit that transforms how you review candidate profiles. What used to take minutes of resume scanning can now be assessed in seconds—thanks to Zia. A Quick Example Say you’re hiring
    • Next Page