Systematic SPF alignment issues with Zoho subdomains

Systematic SPF alignment issues with Zoho subdomains

Analysis Period: August 19 - September 1, 2025
PROBLEM SUMMARY

Multiple Zoho services are causing systematic SPF authentication failures in DMARC reports from major email providers (Google, Microsoft, Zoho). While emails are successfully delivered due to DKIM authentication, the persistent SPF failures may negatively impact sender reputation over time.

TECHNICAL EVIDENCE

Affected Zoho Subdomains:
1. user.zohobookings.com - 8+ SPF failures across multiple reports
2. notifications.zohoflow.com - 52+ SPF failures (highest volume)
3. public.zohoforms.com - 3+ SPF failures  
4. desk-mailer.zohodesk.com - 1+ SPF failure

Provider Confirmation:
- Google Gmail: 15+ DMARC reports showing SPF fail for these domains
- Microsoft Outlook: 3+ DMARC reports confirming same issue
- Zoho Mail: 4+ DMARC reports showing identical pattern

Sample DMARC Record:
```xml
<policy_evaluated>
  <disposition>none</disposition>
  <dkim>pass</dkim>
  <spf>fail</spf>
</policy_evaluated>
<auth_results>
  <dkim>
    <domain>XXXX.com</domain>
    <result>pass</result>
  </dkim>
  <spf>
    <domain>notifications.zohoflow.com</domain>
    <result>pass</result>
  </spf>
</auth_results>
```

**Analysis**: SPF passes for the Zoho subdomain but fails for domain alignment because `notifications.zohoflow.com` is not included in our SPF record for `DOMAIN XXX.com`.

## CRITICAL IPv6 ISSUE

IPv6 Range: `2600:1901:101::/48`  
Problem: Complete DKIM + SPF failure (not just alignment)  
Affected IPs: `::9`, `::15`, `::17`  
Impact: 6+ emails with total authentication failure

This represents a more serious configuration issue requiring immediate attention.

## CURRENT SPF RECORD

```
v=spf1 ip4:SERVERIP +a +mx include:_spf.google.com include:one.zoho.com ~all
```

**Issue**: `include:one.zoho.com` does not cover the subdomains listed above, which have independent SPF records that don't align with customer domains.

## ROOT CAUSE ANALYSIS

Architectural Problem: Zoho services use fragmented SPF architecture where:
- Customer includes `one.zoho.com` in SPF record
- Individual services use separate subdomains with independent SPF records
- No inheritance or redirect mechanism from parent to subdomains
- Results in SPF alignment failure for DMARC evaluation

## EMAIL DELIVERY CONFIRMATION

Emails are being successfully delivered. Example from Gmail logs:
- **Source IP**: 135.84.80.23
- **Status**: Successfully delivered to zoho-flow@DOMAIN.com
- **Authentication**: DKIM pass (prevents quarantine despite SPF fail)

## REQUESTED RESOLUTION

### Option 1 (Preferred): Zoho Infrastructure Fix
Update Zoho subdomain SPF records to include proper redirects or ensure `include:one.zoho.com` covers all service subdomains.

### Option 2: Customer Workaround Documentation  
Provide official list of all Zoho subdomains requiring SPF inclusion, with guidance on SPF flattening to avoid DNS lookup limits.

### Option 3: IPv6 Immediate Fix
Resolve complete authentication failures for IPv6 range `2600:1901:101::/48`.

## BUSINESS IMPACT

- Current: Functional email delivery with SPF failure noise in DMARC reports
- Future Risk: Potential sender reputation degradation with major providers
- Scope: Affects all customers using multiple Zoho services with DMARC monitoring

## SUPPORTING EVIDENCE

I have comprehensive DMARC reports from 20+ daily reports over 3 weeks showing consistent pattern across Google, Microsoft, and Zoho infrastructure. Available upon request for detailed technical analysis.

---

**Expected Resolution**: Technical clarification on proper SPF configuration OR infrastructure fix for subdomain alignment  
**Timeline**: Non-urgent but ongoing reputation concern requiring architectural solution
    • Topic Participants

    • Iss

    • Sticky Posts

    • How to Add Users to your Organization in ZohoMail?

      A better clarity so you can create other users to start using Zoho Mail. You can directly Add Users from the Control Panel to your Organization. You can invite users with the existing email address. If the person (user) already uses ZohoCRM, then you can import users from Zoho CRM. You can also import them using a .csv file. (if you are planning to add them in Bulk)  In this topic, We will be discussing on how to Add and Invite users only.  The Import options are self explanatory. ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________
    • Recent Topics

    • Change Invoice Prices for an Effective Date

      Hi, It would be a really good feature to be able to change the prices on invoices/recurring invoices from an effective date in the event of price increases. For instance, I am in the process of increasing prices that will be effective from a specific
    • "Other Current Asset" accounts as "Paid Through" accounts in Expense

      It would be incredibly useful to be able to assign accounts of type Other Current Asset as Paid Through accounts in Expense. Currently, Other Current Liability are permitted as Paid Through Accounts. This makes sense, as Credit Cards are current liabilities.
    • Multi column open text questions that allows respondents to add rows for additional information

      I need to create a question that has 2 columns with open text, but I also need to allow respondents to click a "+" button, or something similar, so that they can add additional information if they choose to. I've tried using the Multiple Textboxes type
    • Bot Filtering & Apple Mail Privacy Protection Compliance in Zoho Campaigns

      Dear Campaigns Users, The wait is over! We’re excited to announce that the enhanced bot filtering feature is now live in Zoho Campaigns. This update brings greater accuracy to your email campaign reports by distinguishing real user engagement from automated
    • Découvrons les détails qui simplifient vos journées de travail avec Trident

      Nous nous installons dans des routines efficaces et rodées avec le temps. Chaque matin, nous ouvrons nos e-mails, passons aux messages, consultons notre agenda, puis attaquons nos tâches. Ce processus nous semble maîtrisé, mais est-il réellement optimisé
    • Issue with Purchase Rate Showing as “0” After Importing Items List

      Dear Zoho Books Support Team, Good day. I’m reaching out regarding an issue I’m facing while importing my items list into Zoho Books. Despite mapping all fields correctly and including the purchase price for each product in my Excel file, the Purchase
    • API for Task Entity in Zoho Books

      I’m working on automating task creation in Zoho Books via a custom button in the Bills Module. The goal is to create a task in the Tasks Module and assign it to the Finance Team, so they can track progress efficiently. While reviewing Zoho Books documentation,
    • create invoice in zoho books from the zoho forms

      Is there a native way to have create invoice in zoho books, when zoho form is completed?
    • Email undelivered

      GOod Day I am always receiving an uncategorized-bounce to my email. I am not sure why this is happening.
    • Custom Buttons for Mass Actions

      Hello everyone, We’ve just made Custom Buttons in Zoho Recruit even more powerful! You can now create Bulk Action Buttons that let you perform actions on multiple records at once, directly from the List View. What’s new? Until now, custom buttons were
    • Add inventory_valuation_method to items endpooints

      To ensure consistent item creation it would be helpful to have the inventory_valuation_method (FIFO vs WAC) be able to be set at item creation or as an update (consistent with current behavior where it is not allowed for items with existing transactions)
    • Use Zoho to send sales receipts for Gocardless transactions

      I've been using gocardless for years and have d/d mandates set up on there. Each week we get bulk payments from customer d/d's. However, we need to send sales receipts to these customers. So I know I can sync mandates into Zoho, and then I can set up
    • Zoho - Gocardless sales receipts

      I've been using gocardless for years and have d/d mandates set up on there. Each week we get bulk payments from customer d/d's. However, we need to send sales receipts to these customers. So I know I can sync mandates into Zoho, and then I can set up
    • Zoho Notebook Sync problem

      I'm facing a problem with syncing of notebook on android app. It's not syncing. Sometimes it syncs after a day or two.  I created some notes on web notebook but it's not syncing on mobile app. Please help!!!!
    • Introducing Rollup summary in Zoho CRM

      ------------------------------------------Moderated on 5th July'23---------------------------------------------- Rollup summary is now available for all organizations in all the DCs. Hello All, We hope you're well! We're here with an exciting update that
    • Introducing Connected Workflows in Zoho CRM for Everyone : Free Your Teams to Focus on What Matters

      Hello Everyone, We’re thrilled to introduce the next big evolution in Zoho CRM for Everyone -- Connected Workflows. This new feature builds on our commitment to deliver a CRM that’s truly inclusive, adaptable, and designed for consistent collaboration
    • Introducing Connected Records to bring business context to every aspect of your work in Zoho CRM for Everyone

      Hello Everyone, We are excited to unveil phase one of a powerful enhancement to CRM for Everyone - Connected Records, available only in CRM's Nextgen UI. With CRM for Everyone, businesses can onboard all customer-facing teams onto the CRM platform to
    • Cooling-off Period Just Got Better: More Coverage, More Control

      We’ve enhanced the Cooling-off Period feature in Zoho Recruit to give you more control over repeat applications and referrals. This helps you maintain a cleaner, more efficient recruitment pipeline. With this enhancement, you can: Prevent duplicate candidate
    • Cliq iOS can't see shared screen

      Hello, I had this morning a video call with a colleague. She is using Cliq Desktop MacOS and wanted to share her screen with me. I'm on iPad. I noticed, while she shared her screen, I could only see her video, but not the shared screen... Does Cliq iOS is able to display shared screen, or is it somewhere else to be found ? Regards
    • Revenue Management: #7 Revenue Recongition in Construction & Real Estate Industry

      If you are in the construction or real estate business, you are used to long project timelines and progressive invoicing to keep up with your billing. But when does revenue get recognized? Will it happen when the contract gets signed? At different milestones
    • TikTok (and other social platform) Messages and comments of the past

      When I link a social channel, Zoho will show in "Inbox", "Messages" and "Contact" sections the interaction done in the past? (comment, messages...)
    • Email Integration - Zoho CRM - OAuth and IMAP

      Hello, We are attempting to integrate our Microsoft 365 email with Zoho CRM. We are using the documentation at Email Configuration for IMAP and POP3 (zoho.com) We use Microsoft 365 and per their recommendations (and requirements) for secure email we have
    • How do I fix this? Unable to send message; Reason:554 5.1.8 Email Outgoing Blocked.

      How do I fix this? Unable to send message; Reason:554 5.1.8 Email Outgoing Blocked.
    • Restrict Employee mail deletion

      Dear Zoho, Is there a way where i can restrict my employees to delete any mails from their account
    • 554 5.1.8 Email Outgoing Blocked.

      Hi guys, I just singed up for mateusz.nowicki@zoho.com mail and I can't send any mails.. Why? Everytime I try to send something I got error like the one in the screenshot. Please, help me.
    • Zoho IP blocked by SpamHaus

      ERROR CODE :550 - 5.7.0 Your server IP address is in the SpamHaus SBL-XBL database, bye
    • File Upload in Creator's Subfrom

      Hello Sir/Madam, Here is a Problem......... Scenario: In CRM One Custom Module (Payments) have one File Upload Field now we have to Upload that File into Creator's Custom Form (Documents) have one Subform (Documents) in Document Upload Field using Deluge
    • integarting attachments from crm to creator

      when i tried to integrate pdf attachments from crm to creator via deluge i am getting this error {"code":2945,"description":"UPLOAD_RULE_NOT_CONFIGURED"} the code i used is attachments = zoho.crm.getRelatedRecords("Attachments","Sales_Orders",203489100020279XXX8);
    • Error AS101 when adding new email alias

      Hi, I am trying to add apple@(mydomain).com The error AS101 is shown while I try to add the alias.
    • Trigger workflow base on email clic

      Searching the help and forum, I see that there were workflow trigger rules based on email. But now, I can't find this type of trigger when I create a custom workflow. What I'm looking for would be to automate the sending of an email for a new prospect,
    • Bigin Form Acknowledgement

      How to troubleshoot and find out why form acknowledgement is not sending emails after form submission?
    • Option to Customize Career Site URL Without “/jobs/Careers”

      Dear Zoho Recruit Team, I hope you are doing well. We would like to request an enhancement to the Career Site URL structure in Zoho Recruit. In the old version of the career site, our URL was simply: 👉 https://jobs.domain.com However, after moving to
    • Zoho Mail POP & IMAP Server Details

      Hello all! We have been receiving a number of requests regarding the errors while configuring or using Zoho Mail account in POP/ IMAP clients. The server details vary based on your account type and the Datacenter in which your account is setup. Ensure
    • Ever since the new Android App udpates notifications are not working

      notifications are not working for the app is its closed I followed the tutuorial to the notificaction fixed and everythig seems to be right but notifications are not workig
    • Zoho Analytics & Zoho Desk - but not all desks

      I have several desks in our company and one of those is used by our HR department. I want to bring through the data to the shared Zoho Analytics workspace - except for the HR desk. Can this be excluded at data import stage ?
    • Incoming Emails Not Showing Up in Zoho Inbox

      Hi - I have my Zoho email account set up to forward a copy of all incoming emails to a secondary Gmail address, whilst retaining the original email in the Zoho inbox. However, all my incoming emails are currently not showing up in my Zoho inbox, so I'm
    • Form Accessibility

      Hi, is there an update on the accessibility standard of Zoho forms? Are the forms WCAG 2.1 AA compliant? 
    • How to retrieve my following requests on this forum?

      Sorry, but I did not find the proper subforum for this question.
    • How to list emails in a folder, e.g. Inbox, on multiple pages when using Zoho mail webpage?

      Something as shown in the figure. There are totally 50 emails in Sent folder. If "Mail per page" equals 20, then the Sent folder is split into 3 pages. When I wander through Sent folder, I can just select a specific page to jump to. BTW, it seems that
    • Unable to Create Zoho Booking via the Book Appointment API

      Its giving the below error {     "response": {         "errormessage": "Error setting value for the variable:customer_details\n null",         "status": "Error"     } } Request: POST Url: https://www.zohoapis.in/bookings/v1/json/appointment attached Zoho-oauthtoken
    • Next Page