Separate Signature for New & Reply Email

Separate Signature for New & Reply Email

Hello

This drives me crazy:

I  tried to setup 2 different email signatures for my new and reply emails.
And I connect these 2 signatures separately in the settings. (see attached)

No matter how I set it up, the signature is always the new email signature when I reply to someone.

Why this is so complicated with such a simple function?!

Please advise. Thanks